Judge backs Fireblade rider who hit car from behind

20 Posts | Latest reply on 11/01/2013 08:47:42 by Intruder18 | Go to original / last post
rowanblossom's Profile
rowanblossom

In: Manchester
Posts: 29717
18% Karma18% Karma 18% Karma18% Karma

article in Bike magazine  (Jan 13)   Driver's random braking was to blame for crash.   Ride's legal expert, Andrew Dalton has won a case that could have far-reaching implications for riders involved in accidents caused by a driver braking suddenly in front of them.  The case, heard recently at Chichester County Court involved an accident three years ago, when Jason Trafford was riding his Honda Fireblade on a long, straight road and attempting to overtake slower-moving vehicles.   The accident happened when he was tucked in behind a Nissan Micra, preparing to overtake, when the Micra braked heavily for no apparent reason, causing him to hit the rear of the car and suffer a broken wrist.   Judge Levinson found that the rider skilfully decelerated his Fireblade from an estimated 45mph down to the collision speed of 5-10mph but was unable to avoid the collision.  Judgment was awarded 100 per cent in the motorcyclist's favour with no contributory negligence found.                                                                                                                                                                             
Sandi's Profile
Sandi

In: Huddersfield, W
Posts: 17942
69% Karma69% Karma 69% Karma69% Karma

  Nice one! Big smile                                                                                                                                                                             
kwakgirl's Profile
kwakgirl

In: Kilmarnock
Posts: 1402
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

well i never! Big smile                                                                                                                                                                             
JP's Profile
JP

In: Birmingham
Posts: 11141
93% Karma93% Karma 93% Karma93% Karma

About time and I recon the Insureance companys are behind this after meny cases of drivers causing accidents by pulling in front of trucks and braking hard causing accidents just to claim whiplash. An easy 2-3 grand for every person in the car and the car is always full.
rowanblossom's Profile
rowanblossom

In: Manchester
Posts: 29717
18% Karma18% Karma 18% Karma18% Karma

JP, I can't begin to start as to the scams that are pulled...I used to work PI fraud....its truly horrifying what people come up with they don't give a monkeys as to the damage that is caused physically and mentally to their "targets", all that matters is they get the money.   And the incident rate always, always goes up exponentionally in a recession.  Some insurers just pay out as its easier, quicker and most importantly cheaper for them.      Completely changed the way I drove a car within a week of starting that job I can tell you.    I bike the same way.   Never trust anyone else on the road.     Makes me overly cautious at times...but I figure better cautious than hurt (or worse)   I am just glad that the Judge had the balls to make this decision.  And good on Andrew Dalton for fighting for this outcome.                                                                                                                                                                                
Matt's Profile
Matt

In: Veldhoven
Posts: 8053
100% Karma100% Karma 100% Karma100% Karma

Wow!  Unbelievable and about time!                                                                                                                                                                             
Emzed's Profile
Emzed

In: Pickering
Posts: 7151
20% Karma20% Karma 20% Karma20% Karma

I have to agree Matt

                                                                                                                                                                             
bcjone's Profile
bcjone

In: Ilford
Posts: 2
4% Karma4% Karma 4% Karma4% Karma

Common sense making a welcome return....?                                                                                                                                                                             
Intruder18's Profile
Intruder18

In: Colne
Posts: 239
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

JP we have installed cameras in all 35 of our Trucks and they record constantly .. it has saved us over £20-000 worth of damage by third parties already ... Best thing we have ever done . I am contemplating fitting a small camera to he front of my bike that records onto an SD card for similar reasons .. And it will show how some people drive and react around Motorcyclists ..
Emzed's Profile
Emzed

In: Pickering
Posts: 7151
20% Karma20% Karma 20% Karma20% Karma

  A smart move Intruder Approve   A camera on a bike is a great insurance against the morons who try to kill us Thumbs Up   I recommend the fitting of one to any bike which "mixes" with traffic Approve   Be careful out there Wink   There are some idiots and even more "murderers" Shocked                                                                                                                                                                                 
MjN's Profile
MjN

In: Basildon
Posts: 189
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

Result.

All I can say is trust no one...not even thy sein. :/                                                                                                                                                                             
JP's Profile
JP

In: Birmingham
Posts: 11141
93% Karma93% Karma 93% Karma93% Karma

intruder18 interesting saving on claims the company I work for looked at it but it got kicked out by the union due to stupid ideas from some of the management saying that thay wanted the cams to record the drivers cab aswell you can see the problems that would cause.                                                                                                                                                                               
Roachy's Profile
Roachy

In: West Yorks
Posts: 1042
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

"tucked in" - Poor choice of words in the article as it suggests the rider was up the arse of the car he was following which I'm sure he wasn't otherwise it's very doubtful the ruling would have been 100% in the rider's favour.                                                                                                                                                                                   
Intruder18's Profile
Intruder18

In: Colne
Posts: 239
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

Just an update .. Camera has been delivered for my bike .. All looks ok it works well recording wise. My bars are a little big for the bracket so a little modification needed .. I will post pictures when I've had the chance to fit it :-)                                                                                                                                                                              
rossoandy21's Profile
rossoandy21

In: ashford
Posts: 1621
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

be wary of including the view of ya speedo unless u a 'saint' !!                                                                                                                                                                             
Intruder18's Profile
Intruder18

In: Colne
Posts: 239
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I'm no saint pal .... Speedo not in th camera view .. 1st thing I made sure of ... Cheers.                                                                                                                                                                              
Emzed's Profile
Emzed

In: Pickering
Posts: 7151
20% Karma20% Karma 20% Karma20% Karma

    "Saint" Malc LOL       Not yer usual epithet Wink       Congrats on the camera though buddy Thumbs Up   I hope it serves you well Approve   But also, that you never "need" to use the footage Cool                                                                                                                                                                               
Intruder18's Profile
Intruder18

In: Colne
Posts: 239
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

Im not only hoping it serves me well emz but you never know it might help some one else out in the process .... once ive sorted the mount out i will put some footage on the tube and post a link Thumbs Up
                                                                                                                                                                             
Fatbob16's Profile
Fatbob16

In: Buckley
Posts: 683
17% Karma17% Karma 17% Karma17% Karma

Hey nice one Mal.
Would be interesting to see some of the footage recorded on the "beast".
Certainly be few frame of the tractor as you vanish in the distance lol.
Hope you never need to use it in anger buddy.
Keep it lid side up.                                                                                                                                                                              
Intruder18's Profile
Intruder18

In: Colne
Posts: 239
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

Hey Bandito ...The camera is for the front so there would be no footage of your Massey Ferguson on the video sorry Pig Unless i ride around in 3rd gear all day Ouch Thanks Di ......
                                                                                                                                                                             


Remove these advertisements                  Advertise Here
Biker Match is a UK social, events and dating website by bikers, for bikers.  All British motorcyclists are welcome to join our large and exciting community free of charge in search of ride-outs, motorcycling events & rallies, biker dating & relationships, motorcycle help, motorcycle forums, biking news, racing news, motorcycle classifieds or just to get to know other UK bikers.  Create your profile and upload your photos now completely free.
Website copyright 2002-2024 www.bikermatch.co.uk.

Page generated in 0.7969 seconds. There are 530 users online now.

Site tested and secured by Comodo HackerGuardian       Site tested and approved by McAfee SiteAdvisor      Site PCI DSS security approved      Site tested and secured by Comodo HackerProof       Site secured and validated using highest 2048bit encryption