Is Hi Vis a good idea?

78 Posts | Latest reply on 10/06/2012 16:52:29 by Deleted User | Go to original / last post
davidneale's Profile
davidneale

In: London
Posts: 25650
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I realise that there has been discussions on other forums regarding proposed new legislation, part of which is likely to include High Visibility clothing. I was interested in finding out WHO DOES WEAR hi vis in some form. Or who agrees in wearing such clothing?   I must emphasise that this is not to discuss Hi Vis being forced upon us, as that has been gone into on another forum. Just if you wear it or agree with it's use.                                                                                                                                                                             
cavywavy's Profile
cavywavy

In: Ashbourne
Posts: 214
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I dont wear Hi Vis as such but all my gear is textile and has hi viz strips built into it.   And I dont belive its ever made a big diffrence, when I first started ridding I had a hi viz jacket and it didnt seem to stop anyone trying to nock me off. I belive the problem is more to do with ppl just not looking as I tide around I see the ones that do and they have always given me room know I was there. and I see those that dont the accident I had the other month was becuase the driver didnt look. dont matter if I was or wasnt wearing hi viz he would have still hit me.   If they truly want to make a diffrence they should make it so insurance companys carnt do 50/50 and unless I was in the wrong dont side with the car driver. its the only way to make them look make them stop thinking of bikes as 2nd tier road users.   And yes I know there are some planks on bikes to. and it may mean they get away with a few things that they shouldnt but for the mojority it will make car/van/bus/lorry drivers more thoughtfull on the roads if they run the risk of getting hit in the pocket. if I had my way for anyone not driving with due care I would slap points on to.                                                                                                                                                                             
JP's Profile
JP

In: Birmingham
Posts: 11177
98% Karma98% Karma 98% Karma98% Karma

it all depends on what type of hi vis you get. The only safe type on a bike is a railway type, it is held together with velcro and comes in 3 pieces so if you get caught on a passing car its just comes apart. you dont get dragged down the road                                                                                                                                                                               
X Beanz X's Profile
X Beanz X

In: Eaton Bray
Posts: 1306
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I sometimes wear a high vis (I got a think biker printed one) not sure it makes much difference but all depends on the weather too , esp if the sun is low in the sky I wear it or when rainy/foggy.....I like to think it makes me more visable and safer out there but who knows........nice to have the option and not to be forced into it...
Holmfirthgirl's Profile
Holmfirthgirl

In: Larkfield
Posts: 3156
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I've got a hi Viz....BUT I prefer to wear my Swan Yamaha Jacket (over me leathers) as it's BRIGHT YELLOW all over....so you can see ALL of me (well me top half anyway)...whether it makes any difference or not I don't know asI don't really go out that often...at the moment......
Riggy66's Profile
Riggy66

In: Huddersfield
Posts: 447
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

In my opinion - and it's a very humble one ... People who have never ridden a bike simply do not expect us to be in their way. Whether it's alongside them in traffic or at roundabouts etc.
I do my best to be visible but they text, listen to music, make calls and are chatting to passengers.
They sit in a comfortable, re-inforced metal box with air-bags and feel far too safe. As long as they feel nothing can harm them they will never consider that their actions could hurt any one else.
It really is up to us to be as visible (or audible) as possible. So I do wear a vis belt in the worse weather or when it's dark. It's my life after all.                                                                                                                                                                             
Deleted Member's Profile
Deleted Member

In: NA
Posts: 0
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

My jacket and waterproofs and packback all have Hi Viz stripes....if we can be more visible to those who sit in thrir metal cacoons I dont have a problem. If a bit of reflective tape makes me more visible to other less bike conscious road users and I arrive alive I dont mind Big smile                                                                                                                                                                             
Sandi's Profile
Sandi

In: Huddersfield, W
Posts: 17948
92% Karma92% Karma 92% Karma92% Karma

  I used to wear a hi vis waistcoat and was almost railroaded out of the way, twice, by car drivers, both times while I was waiting in traffic in daylight. They were attempting to change lane, unfortunately they wanted the one I was in, at the exact same place.   In my experience it made no difference. Thumbs Down                                                                                                                                                                             
thehairyone's Profile
thehairyone

In: Boston
Posts: 173
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

Last autumn I followed a motorcyclist in a Hi Vis jacket, some of the time he was visible but against the setting sun and autumn vegetation he was all but invisible, his bike which was black was visible. so good idea maybe, but i would like to see if there is any proof as to the value of Hi Vis for motorcyclists.
Out of curiosity, have you noticed that putting on a Santa suit at Christmas makes you instantly visible, perhaps red suits are the answerSmile
                                                                                                                                                                             
dustin666's Profile
dustin666

In: carlisle
Posts: 1275
13% Karma13% Karma 13% Karma13% Karma

my bike's headlight is fairly hi viz , my 44 ton truck is also quite conspicuous. They still pull out infront of me. There is none so blind as them that will not see. A 6 foot Xmas tree , fully lit on your back seat and the duckers will still crash into you . Some people should not be allowed to drive . . dressing up as a big banana will not protect you from the dummies . It'll just make you easier to find in the aftermath. Dusty ...
nondomesticgoddess's Profile
nondomesticgoddess

In: rotherham
Posts: 26
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

i have a waterproof hiviz jacket i wear over my leathers that i tend to wear if i'm doing a long haul/motorway trip... got several of the vests from when i had horses.. one says please pass wide and slow... lol Wink been tempted to wear it lol
Deleted Member's Profile
Deleted Member

In: NA
Posts: 0
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I don,t wear it , thats my choice but i do wonder by so many wearing it aren,t they feeding those in power that would make it compulsory .                                                                                                                                                                             
Sandi's Profile
Sandi

In: Huddersfield, W
Posts: 17948
92% Karma92% Karma 92% Karma92% Karma

  firetrap I expect they, like me, probably thought/think they are safer when in reality we aren't.   Like Dusty said, they just make it easier to find us in the aftermath.                                                                                                                                                                             
davidneale's Profile
davidneale

In: London
Posts: 25650
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I never thought of that one Sandi !                                                                                                                                                                             
Sandi's Profile
Sandi

In: Huddersfield, W
Posts: 17948
92% Karma92% Karma 92% Karma92% Karma

  Neither did I David.                                                                                                                                                                             
Vladamir's Profile
Vladamir

In: sheffield
Posts: 684
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

I bought a textile jacket and chose  it because its partly hi vis. But when driving my car I find I usually see the bikes headlight before I see any Hi Vis clothing the rider is wearing                                                                                                                                                                             
Gloom's Profile
Gloom

In: Southport
Posts: 216
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

MAG did a test on high viz kit at junctions and it seems it makes no difference unless it's moving across your vision. I personally don't like it and don't wear it while riding.                                                                                                                                                                                
davidneale's Profile
davidneale

In: London
Posts: 25650
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma

Thanks for your response and keeping on thread so far people. I can see some interesting issues developing here. When I have received more feedback, I will summaries the responses.   Where some people wear partly Hi Vis clothing, it would be good to know if that is Dayglow or night refective or both.   Keep your answers coming please.                                                                                                                                                                             
JP's Profile
JP

In: Birmingham
Posts: 11177
98% Karma98% Karma 98% Karma98% Karma

There is one other point, when you do get knocked off you have a stronge case for the driver not looking and the police siding with you and prosicuting                                                                                                                                                                              
Deleted Member's Profile
Deleted Member

In: NA
Posts: 0
0% Karma0% Karma 0% Karma0% Karma



only the reflective strips are any goodI remember a police officer testifying that hi-viz made no difference 

often wear camo and can see car drivers pointing at me and shaking their heads at my guess thinking "what a twat" while I`m think thank God the twat didnt pull out and it would have been better if his/her dad had

to see they need to look                                                                                                                                                                              


Remove these advertisements                  Advertise Here
Biker Match is a UK social, events and dating website by bikers, for bikers.  All British motorcyclists are welcome to join our large and exciting community free of charge in search of ride-outs, motorcycling events & rallies, biker dating & relationships, motorcycle help, motorcycle forums, biking news, racing news, motorcycle classifieds or just to get to know other UK bikers.  Create your profile and upload your photos now completely free.
Website copyright 2002-2024 www.bikermatch.co.uk.

Page generated in 2.2188 seconds. There are 2056 users online now.

Site tested and secured by Comodo HackerGuardian       Site tested and approved by McAfee SiteAdvisor      Site PCI DSS security approved      Site tested and secured by Comodo HackerProof       Site secured and validated using highest 2048bit encryption